The Subtle Art of Dharma

 

The Subtle Art of Dharma

Blog 1 – 03/07/2021

 

 

What man of mettle will have the patience when he sees his rivals prosper and himself decline?

 

This is the opening line of my latest read, which turned out to be a splendid and insightful book by Gurcharan Das

 


 

The book is an insight into the moral and ethical behavior of each character of the Mahabharata. The way they behave, why they behave as they do, and why is it important for the ruler of the society to ensure his subjects and himself adhere to “Dharma”. It addresses the most important and crucial question that befalls people, especially in these current pandemic times, “why”. Why me? Why should one be good? Why should I stand in line for vaccines when others can use “jacks”? Why should I not envy my neighbor, my brother or Mr. Mukesh Ambani? Why is it so hard to be selfless? Why should I follow my “dharma”? What is my “dharma”? What end result will it do me, if I follow the so called “restrictions” set out by society? A man steeped in Chinese culture would ask, why should I celebrate my success with a feeling of guilt? Why and how does the behavior of a single individual impact society? Why should one follow a moral diktat of, say, not lying or cheating? Especially when one is denied personal gain?

 

When does it become morally correct to fight for one’s rights? When is it justified to use violence in protection or achieving one’s right? Who decides what is one’s right? Is a king justified in killing his brother to step on the throne? Is the second generation of a business family right in breaking the business and splitting up? Is an open marriage justified? Should husbands and wife be bound to each other for their life, especially when the bond is “sanctioned” by God? Is divorce justified in all cases? When would separation be justified, and when would it be incorrect?

 

These are all questions for which, every person would have a different answer. Where should one look for answers? Who, if at all anybody, does have a right answer? Is there even an answer? These are some of the countless questions which have confronted human beings for eternity. The author tries to locate the answers of a few of these questions in the Mahabharata, the greatest epic and the longest poem in History. The Mahabharata is truly a mirror which forces us the reflect upon our behavior, why we behave as we do, and what we should do, in order to attain higher goals. Is there even something as a “higher goal”? There are some questions for which the Pandavas (our heroes of this epic) do not get any answers till the end, which are then left open to interpretation. Consider these age old questions, answered through the prism of modern life, by borrowing various interpretations from different authors, philosophers and contemporary theorists, economists and political scientists.

 

The author then tries to relate how the emotion expressed by each character is already within each of us, both the good sides and the bad sides. It is the compared with the business and the political world, and how the emotion/question has influenced Indian public life for centuries.

 

We shall start on the journey to understand the epic, through the lens of the author, and try to make sense of why we do what we do through a series of blog posts – one for each of the characters considered in the book. I shall consider this endeavor to have succeeded if the reader decides to start the book, if influenced by this blog!

 

Stay tuned!


गौतम पाटणकर 


Comments

  1. Rima Tripathy3 July 2021 at 12:14

    Thank you so much for sharing all this wonderful info about the book.It is so appreciated...

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

I Act Because I must

Image
  I Act Because I Must Blog 2 – 24/07/2021     Be Intent on the Act - कर्मण्येवाधिकारस्ते मा फलेषु कदाचन । मा कर्मफलहेतुर्भुर्मा ते संगोऽस्त्वकर्मणि ॥   We had begun on a journey to understand the moral questions often posed to Humans, in the previous blog, we discussed about the questions, where to look for the answers, if any and how to apply them in real life. We shall discuss all this through the prism of the book "The difficulty of being good" by Gurcharan Das.  This series of blog posts shall also simultaneously act as a chapter by chapter book review (Not necessarily in the same order), with my own thoughts on the same.  We begin this journey to understand this book, with the most quoted, and perhaps the least understood verse of the Bhagwat Geeta, which simply encourages to work on the action, not on the fruits. All of us would have heard somebody utter this verse, without understanding the magnanimity of the words, let alone the deep philosophy
Read more

The Home of the Celibate

Image
The Home of the Celibate The supreme court seems to have gained a new enthusiasm in disposing of long pending issues. Starting with the triple talaq bill, it finally put to rest the contentious ram janmabhoomi title dispute after hearing all arguments from 6th August 2019, till it finally declared the verdict on 9th November 2019. Another issue, often referred to as the ram janmabhoomi of the south, also needs quick and precise disposal by the court. This is the issue of the sabrimala women entry case. Judges have often been back and forth on their views about this petition. Multiple appeals, dissenting judgements and now finally, a review petition is in place, which is to be decided by the court. The two cases mentioned above provide an issue which is unique to India. For understanding the issue, we need to look at the historical, cultural and legal developments in the country to come at a reasonable conclusion. What is the sabrimala case? Sabrimala is
Read more

President of the city

Image
We call this nation of ours as a democracy, a rule for the people, by the people and of the people. The constitution of India is also "given to the people by themselves", meaning that it has not been given by any king or prince. Nobody has a "divine right" to rule the people except they themselves. However, is it a reality?  Mahatma Gandhi essayed a big role in deepening of democratic roots in the country, to the last man or woman. He ensured that people trust in the system even if they have had nothing to eat for days, no medical care for the sick, schools for the children or justice for the marginalized. It is creditable that people have not revolted and broken the system into anarchy despite decades of misgovernance, lavish displays of wealth against abject poverty, India faring so low on various hunger, malnutrition and happiness indexes. (India ranked 102 out of 112 countries in the global hunger index) It is creditable that democratic roots
Read more